Nutraceuticals Third Party Manufacturers in India

Looking for nutraceuticals third party manufacturers in India? Explore manufacturing, custom formulations, quality testing and private label solutions.

Aniket

11/16/202616 min read

Why Are Indian Supplement Brands Turning Towards Nutraceuticals Third Party Manufacturers in India?

Starting a supplement brand in India sounds straightforward until the actual manufacturing work begins. An entrepreneur may have a product idea, a name for the brand, a few packaging references and even a marketing plan. But then questions start coming up. Where will the product be manufactured? Who will arrange the raw materials? How will the formulation be finalised? What about testing, packaging, labelling and regulatory requirements?

This is where nutraceuticals third party manufacturers in India become important.

Instead of investing in a manufacturing facility, machinery, production staff and quality control infrastructure, supplement brands can work with an established manufacturing company. The manufacturer handles the production side while the brand owner concentrates on distribution, customer relationships, marketing and sales.

For new entrepreneurs, this arrangement can make entering the nutraceutical industry more manageable. Even established supplement companies use third party manufacturing when they want to introduce additional products without expanding their own production facilities.

India has a growing market for dietary supplements, sports nutrition, vitamins, minerals, herbal formulations and specialised wellness products. This has created opportunities for gym owners, doctors, healthcare entrepreneurs, distributors and online supplement businesses.

However, choosing a manufacturing partner is not simply about finding someone who can produce a powder or capsule at the lowest price. Product consistency, ingredient quality, formulation knowledge and regulatory compliance matter just as much.

That is why brands are paying closer attention to the capabilities of nutraceuticals third party manufacturers in India before committing to a production arrangement.

What Products Can You Develop Through Third Party Nutraceutical Manufacturing?

One reason third party manufacturing has become popular is the variety of products that can be developed under a single brand. An entrepreneur does not necessarily have to restrict the business to one category.

For example, someone starting with protein supplements may later want to introduce creatine, multivitamins, pre-workout products or recovery supplements. Working with a manufacturer that understands different dosage forms can make such expansion easier.

The product category should be decided according to the intended customer, positioning, formulation requirements and applicable regulations.

1. Protein powders and sports nutrition

Protein supplements remain an important category for fitness focused brands.

Products may include:

  • Whey protein concentrate

  • Whey protein isolate

  • Plant based protein blends

  • Mass gainers

  • Protein blends for specialised nutritional requirements

  • Recovery and post workout formulations

A brand planning to launch whey protein should pay particular attention to protein content, ingredient specifications, amino acid profile, flavour development and testing.

I have seen how much attention brands give to packaging design while overlooking the importance of checking the actual protein content and raw material specifications. That can become an expensive mistake.

2. Vitamins and mineral supplements

This category serves a wider audience, including people interested in everyday nutritional support.

Common formulations include vitamin C, vitamin D, vitamin B complex, zinc, calcium, magnesium and multivitamin combinations.

These products can be manufactured in tablet, capsule, powder or liquid formats, depending on the formulation and regulatory classification.

3. Herbal and Ayurvedic nutraceutical products

Indian consumers have a long association with herbal ingredients. This creates opportunities for brands interested in botanical based supplements.

Some commonly used ingredients include ashwagandha, turmeric, amla, moringa and other botanical extracts.

However, brands should not assume that every herbal formulation automatically qualifies as a nutraceutical. Product classification, ingredient permissions, dosage and labelling requirements need to be checked before manufacturing.

4. Capsules and tablets

Capsules and tablets are practical formats for brands selling daily nutritional supplements.

They can be used for:

  • Multivitamin combinations

  • Mineral supplements

  • Herbal formulations

  • Joint health products

  • Specialised nutritional blends

Capsule manufacturing and tablet manufacturing involve different production considerations. Powder flow, compression properties, disintegration and stability all influence the final product.

5. Other specialised supplement categories

Depending on the manufacturing facility and product requirements, brands may also explore creatine, pre-workout formulations, omega fatty acid supplements, digestive health products, liquid supplements and other specialised nutritional products.

MGVS LifeSciences works within the nutraceutical manufacturing space, supporting businesses interested in developing products for their own supplement brands.

Before finalising a product list, it is sensible to discuss the formulation, intended market, packaging format and regulatory requirements with the manufacturer.

How Does the Third Party Manufacturing Process Work From Formulation to Dispatch?

Many first time supplement entrepreneurs expect manufacturing to begin immediately after they share a product name and packaging design.

In practice, several decisions must be made before the first production batch is ready.

A proper manufacturing process starts with understanding what the brand actually wants to sell. A protein powder intended for regular gym users may have different formulation and flavour requirements from a premium sports nutrition product positioned for experienced athletes.

Here is how the process generally moves forward.

Step 1: Product discussion and requirement assessment

The brand owner shares the product category, target audience, expected selling price, preferred ingredients and packaging requirements.

At this stage, the manufacturer should understand whether the client wants a ready made formulation or a customised product.

It is also useful to discuss the intended sales channels. A product sold through gyms may require different pack sizes and positioning from one sold through an online marketplace.

Step 2: Formulation selection

Once the requirements are clear, the formulation is reviewed.

The discussion may involve ingredient selection, ingredient quantities, nutritional composition, flavour profile and dosage format.

For example, a brand planning to launch a chocolate flavoured whey protein should discuss sweetness, solubility, texture and taste. A formulation that looks good on paper may still need flavour adjustments before it becomes suitable for commercial production.

Step 3: Raw material procurement

After formulation approval, the required ingredients are arranged.

Manufacturers generally work with approved suppliers and evaluate raw materials against their specifications. Depending on the ingredient, this may involve checking identity, purity, microbiological parameters and other relevant quality requirements.

Raw material availability can also affect production timelines. Imported ingredients, specialised extracts and certain flavouring materials may require additional procurement time.

Step 4: Sample development and approval

Where sampling is part of the manufacturing arrangement, the brand can evaluate the product before proceeding with commercial production.

This is particularly important for protein powders, mass gainers, pre-workout supplements and flavoured nutritional products.

A sample should be assessed for taste, appearance, mixing behaviour and other relevant product characteristics.

Step 5: Commercial manufacturing

After the required approvals and production arrangements are completed, the manufacturing process begins.

Depending on the product, this may involve weighing, blending, granulation, encapsulation, tablet compression, filling or other suitable processes.

Production conditions and quality checks should follow the applicable manufacturing procedures.

Step 6: Packaging and labelling

Packaging is not a small administrative activity. It affects product protection, shelf presentation, storage and customer experience.

Brands may choose jars, bottles, pouches, blister packs or other suitable packaging formats.

The label must contain the applicable information, including product identity, ingredients, nutritional information, declarations, manufacturer details, batch information and other mandatory particulars.

Step 7: Final checks and dispatch

Before dispatch, the finished product should undergo the applicable quality checks and release procedures.

The brand should clarify what batch documents, test reports and other records will be provided.

After approval and completion of dispatch arrangements, products are packed and sent to the agreed destination.

One point worth discussing before signing the manufacturing agreement is responsibility for transportation, transit damage and warehouse handling. These details can create unnecessary disputes if nobody discusses them at the beginning.

Raw Material Sourcing and Quality Testing: What Should Brands Actually Check?

A supplement may have an attractive label, premium packaging and a convincing product description. But the actual quality begins much earlier, with the ingredients used during manufacturing.

This is one area where new brands should spend more time asking questions.

When evaluating nutraceuticals third party manufacturers in India, do not stop at asking whether the company follows quality standards. Ask how the manufacturer evaluates raw materials and what testing procedures apply to the finished product.

Raw material specifications matter

Every ingredient should have appropriate specifications based on its identity and intended use.

For instance, a protein ingredient should not be evaluated only by its supplier name or commercial grade description.

Brands developing whey protein products should understand:

  • Protein content and applicable testing methods

  • Ingredient identity and composition

  • Moisture levels

  • Microbiological quality

  • Relevant contaminant limits

  • Supplier documentation

For herbal extracts, the discussion may include botanical identity, extract ratio, marker compounds, purity and contaminant testing, depending on the ingredient.

The exact testing requirements vary according to the material and applicable standards.

What happens during protein testing?

Protein testing deserves particular attention in sports nutrition.

A brand selling whey protein should understand how protein content is verified and which analytical method is being used. Methods such as Kjeldahl and Dumas are commonly used for protein estimation, although interpretation depends on the sample and testing context.

It is also important to understand that protein estimation alone does not establish the complete quality of a protein powder.

The brand should consider the ingredient specifications, formulation composition and relevant amino acid profile information.

A product containing a high protein percentage on paper still needs proper verification through suitable testing.

Finished product testing

Quality control should not end when the raw materials enter the manufacturing facility.

Finished products may require checks for:

  • Appearance, colour and odour

  • Weight variation

  • Nutritional composition

  • Microbiological parameters

  • Moisture content

  • Disintegration or dissolution, where relevant

  • Packaging integrity

  • Product specific quality parameters

The testing plan should be appropriate for the formulation and product category.

Certificates and manufacturing standards

Brands often ask manufacturers about GMP, ISO and other quality certifications.

These can provide useful information about the manufacturing facility and its quality management practices. However, a certificate should never replace actual product testing or document verification.

Ask for relevant certificates, their validity, issuing authority and scope.

I might be wrong here, but this does not apply to every manufacturer. Some smaller manufacturers may have strong product specific processes despite having a different certification profile. What matters is verifying the actual facility, its applicable licences, quality systems and compliance status rather than relying on a certificate name alone.

Documentation brands should request

Depending on the product and manufacturing arrangement, useful documents may include:

  • Raw material specifications

  • Certificates of Analysis

  • Finished product test reports

  • Batch manufacturing records

  • Product specifications

  • Applicable manufacturing licences and certificates

  • Stability and shelf life supporting information

A manufacturer should be able to explain which documents are available for each batch.

I still remember seeing cartons stacked in a warehouse during peak summer. The packaging looked perfectly fine from the outside, but storage conditions were something the business owner had not considered.

That is why quality discussions should also cover product storage, transportation and handling after manufacturing.

Custom Formulations vs Ready Made Products: Which Option Makes More Business Sense?

This decision can influence the entire business model of a supplement brand.

Some entrepreneurs want to launch products quickly without spending too much time developing a formulation. Others want something different from the products already available in the market.

Both approaches have their place.

The right choice depends on investment capacity, target customers, product positioning, sales strategy and the level of differentiation required.

Ready made formulations for quicker market entry

Ready made formulations are generally suitable for entrepreneurs who want to start with an existing product composition offered by the manufacturer.

For example, a gym owner planning to introduce a basic multivitamin or protein supplement under a private label arrangement may not need an entirely new formulation.

The brand can discuss available options, select a suitable product and work on packaging, branding and other commercial requirements.

This approach may reduce formulation development time, although manufacturing schedules, ingredient availability, approvals and packaging arrangements still affect the overall launch timeline.

It is worth considering when:

  • You are launching your first supplement brand.

  • Your initial investment is limited.

  • You want to test market demand.

  • The existing formulation meets your product requirements.

  • You do not need a highly differentiated ingredient combination.

Custom formulations for a distinct product identity

Custom formulation involves developing or modifying a product according to specific requirements.

A sports nutrition startup may want a particular protein blend. A wellness brand may prefer a combination of vitamins, minerals and botanical ingredients. A doctor associated with a supplement brand may want a product developed around a defined nutritional concept, subject to applicable regulatory requirements.

In such situations, custom nutraceutical formulation can be useful.

However, custom development requires more discussion. Ingredient compatibility, formulation stability, taste, texture, dosage, ingredient sourcing and testing all need attention.

A custom formulation can also involve higher development costs, additional sampling and longer preparation time.

How do the two options compare?

Factor

Ready Made Formulation

Custom Formulation

Development time

Generally shorter

Usually longer

Product composition

Existing option

Developed around requirements

Initial development cost

Often lower

May be higher

Differentiation

Depends on existing product

More flexibility

Sampling

May be limited or straightforward

May require multiple trials

Suitable for

New and budget conscious brands

Brands seeking product differentiation

An important commercial consideration

Many entrepreneurs focus heavily on MOQ when selecting a manufacturing partner. It is understandable because inventory investment directly affects cash flow.

But quality can matter more than MOQ in certain situations.

Suppose two manufacturers offer a similar protein product. One quotes a lower manufacturing price but cannot clearly explain ingredient specifications, testing and batch documentation. The other offers better transparency and a more reliable quality process at a slightly higher price.

Choosing the cheaper option may not be a sensible business decision.

Sometimes clients negotiate ₹20 per kg while overlooking product quality, and that decision becomes expensive later.

There is another side to this decision. A custom formulation is not automatically better than an existing one. If the ready made formulation meets your intended product specifications and customer expectations, spending extra money on custom development may not provide enough commercial value.

For MGVS LifeSciences, the discussion should begin with what the brand wants to manufacture, who will buy it and what product specifications are required. From there, the manufacturing approach can be evaluated.

A useful starting point is to prepare a product requirement sheet containing the proposed product category, ingredient preferences, pack size, expected order quantity and target market. It makes the first manufacturing discussion much more productive.

MOQ, Manufacturing Costs and Delivery Timelines: What Should New Brands Expect?

One of the first questions an entrepreneur asks while contacting nutraceuticals third party manufacturers in India is simple: What is the minimum order quantity, and how much will manufacturing cost?

It is a fair question. A new supplement brand may have limited capital, uncertain market demand and no previous sales history. Ordering thousands of units without knowing how customers will respond can create unnecessary financial pressure.

However, MOQ is not a fixed number across the nutraceutical industry. It depends on the product category, formulation, packaging material, ingredient availability and production requirements.

For example, the MOQ for a basic vitamin tablet may differ considerably from that of a customised flavoured protein powder. The machinery, raw materials and production arrangements are different.

Why do manufacturers have minimum order quantities?

Manufacturing involves several costs that remain almost the same regardless of whether a company produces a small or large batch.

These may include:

  • Production line preparation and cleaning

  • Raw material procurement

  • Packaging material arrangements

  • Labour and operational expenses

  • Quality testing

  • Batch documentation

  • Labelling and printing arrangements

Consider a brand that wants to manufacture 200 jars of a specialised protein powder. The manufacturer may need to arrange ingredients, prepare the blending equipment, organise packaging and conduct quality checks.

The same preparation activities may be necessary for a considerably larger batch. This is one reason smaller production quantities can have a higher per unit cost.

What determines nutraceutical manufacturing costs?

There is no reliable universal price for third party supplement manufacturing. Two products belonging to the same category can have very different costs.

The major pricing factors include:

Cost factor

How it affects pricing

Raw materials

Ingredient quality, origin and availability influence costs

Formulation

Complex combinations may require additional development work

Product format

Powder, capsule, tablet and liquid production involve different processes

Packaging

Jars, pouches, bottles and specialised packaging have different costs

Testing

Product specific testing and documentation add expenses

Order quantity

Larger batches may reduce per unit production costs

Transportation

Distance, shipment size and handling affect delivery expenses

For instance, a whey protein product using imported ingredients may have a different cost structure from a formulation using locally sourced ingredients.

Similarly, custom flavour development can involve additional sampling and adjustment expenses.

When comparing quotations from nutraceuticals third party manufacturers in India, ask for a clear cost breakdown. Check whether the quotation includes packaging, labels, testing, taxes, transportation and any development charges.

A quotation that looks cheaper initially may not represent the actual final cost.

How long does manufacturing take?

Delivery timelines depend on the product and the readiness of the required materials.

A basic formulation with readily available ingredients may move faster than a customised product requiring imported ingredients, flavour trials or specialised packaging.

A typical manufacturing arrangement may involve the following stages:

  1. Initial product discussion and quotation.

  2. Formulation selection or development.

  3. Sample approval, where required.

  4. Raw material and packaging procurement.

  5. Production and quality checks.

  6. Labelling, packing and dispatch.

New brands should also account for unexpected delays. A packaging supplier may take longer than expected, a particular flavour may require another trial, or a raw material shipment may get delayed.

I would suggest keeping a reasonable buffer between the expected manufacturing completion date and the actual product launch date. Planning a marketing campaign around an unconfirmed dispatch date can create problems.

FSSAI Compliance, Product Labelling and Certifications Every Supplement Brand Should Understand

A supplement brand can have a good formulation and attractive packaging, but regulatory compliance still needs proper attention before the product reaches customers.

This is particularly important for entrepreneurs entering the Indian nutraceutical market for the first time.

FSSAI requirements are not limited to printing a licence number on the product label. The product category, permitted ingredients, nutritional claims, manufacturing arrangement and declarations must all be considered.

Brands working with nutraceuticals third party manufacturers in India should discuss regulatory responsibilities at the beginning rather than waiting until packaging artwork is ready.

Understanding FSSAI requirements

The Food Safety and Standards Authority of India regulates food products, including health supplements and nutraceuticals, under the applicable food safety framework.

The Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006, and relevant regulations provide the broader regulatory structure.

The Food Safety and Standards Regulations covering Health Supplements, Nutraceuticals, Food for Special Dietary Use, Food for Special Medical Purpose, Functional Foods and Novel Foods are particularly relevant to this industry.

A product must be classified correctly before its ingredients, composition and claims are finalised.

For example, a business cannot simply classify every herbal capsule as a nutraceutical. The actual ingredients, intended use, composition and applicable regulatory provisions determine the appropriate category.

Brands should verify whether the ingredients and their proposed quantities are permitted under the relevant regulations.

Why product labels need careful review

Labelling mistakes can create delays and compliance problems.

A supplement label generally needs to address applicable declarations such as:

  • Name and category of the food product

  • Ingredient list

  • Nutritional information

  • Recommended usage instructions

  • Applicable warnings and precautions

  • Net quantity

  • Batch or lot identification

  • Manufacturing and expiry or best before details, as applicable

  • Manufacturer and brand owner details

  • FSSAI licence information

  • Storage instructions

  • Customer care information and other mandatory declarations

The exact requirements depend on the product category and applicable regulations.

Health claims also deserve special attention. A brand should not make unsupported promises about curing diseases, treating medical conditions or guaranteeing health outcomes.

For example, saying that a supplement supports normal nutritional requirements is very different from claiming that it cures a particular medical condition.

A packaging designer may understand colours, fonts and layout, but regulatory label review requires a different kind of knowledge.

Who needs an FSSAI licence?

The brand owner and manufacturer should clarify their respective licensing and registration obligations.

In third party manufacturing arrangements, the manufacturer operates under the applicable licence for its manufacturing activities. The brand owner may also require an appropriate FSSAI registration or licence depending on its business activities and role in the food supply chain.

Do not assume that the manufacturer's licence automatically covers every activity undertaken by the brand owner.

This is an important point to clarify before signing the manufacturing agreement.

What about GMP and ISO certifications?

Manufacturers may hold different certifications depending on their facility, operations and quality management systems.

Some commonly discussed standards include:

Certification or standard

What it generally indicates

GMP

Good manufacturing practices and controlled production procedures

ISO 22000

Food safety management system

HACCP

Hazard analysis and control of food safety hazards

ISO 9001

Quality management system

These standards and certifications serve different purposes. They should not be treated as interchangeable.

Ask for copies of relevant certificates and verify their validity, scope and issuing organisation.

For current regulatory information, brands can refer to the official FSSAI website and the FoSCoS portal.

It is better to resolve compliance questions during product development than to discover a labelling issue after thousands of printed labels have arrived.

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Selecting Nutraceuticals Third Party Manufacturers in India

Selecting a manufacturer is one of those business decisions that may look simple during the first meeting but can affect the brand for years.

An entrepreneur may receive quotations from five companies, compare their prices and select the cheapest option. But manufacturing capability cannot be judged through a quotation alone.

There are several mistakes worth avoiding.

1. Selecting a manufacturer only because of low pricing

Price matters, particularly for startups operating with limited capital.

But an unusually low quotation deserves further examination.

Ask whether the price includes the same ingredient specifications, packaging quality, testing and documentation as competing offers.

If one manufacturer quotes for a premium ingredient and another offers a cheaper alternative, comparing only the final amount can be misleading.

2. Not checking the manufacturing facility

A website, product catalogue or sales presentation cannot establish the actual manufacturing capability of a company.

Ask about the production facility, machinery, quality control procedures and relevant licences.

Where possible, arrange a facility visit or request a proper virtual inspection.

Check whether the manufacturer actually produces the required product category or depends on another company for certain manufacturing activities.

3. Ignoring sample approval

A product may sound excellent during a discussion but taste completely different when the sample arrives.

This happens particularly with flavoured protein powders, mass gainers and herbal formulations.

Before approving commercial production, evaluate the sample against the agreed specifications.

For powders, check taste, texture, solubility and appearance. For capsules and tablets, consider their physical characteristics and relevant quality requirements.

Keep a record of the approved sample and agreed specifications.

4. Assuming all raw materials are equal

Ingredient quality can vary according to supplier, grade, origin and specifications.

A brand planning to sell whey protein should not accept a generic statement that the product contains premium whey.

Ask for ingredient details and suitable supporting documentation.

The same applies to herbal extracts, vitamins, minerals and specialised nutritional ingredients.

5. Overlooking packaging and storage

Packaging problems can affect the product after it leaves the manufacturing line.

A poorly selected container may allow moisture exposure. An unsuitable seal may affect product protection. Incorrect label dimensions can create printing and application issues.

Discuss packaging compatibility, sealing, storage conditions and transportation arrangements.

I once came across a business owner who had planned the entire product launch around a particular jar design, only to discover that the selected packaging was not suitable for the intended filling arrangement.

Small details like these matter.

6. Not discussing ownership of the formulation

This is particularly relevant when working with custom formulations.

The brand should clarify whether the formulation is proprietary, shared, manufacturer developed or based on an existing product.

Discuss confidentiality, future production rights, changes in ingredient suppliers and whether the same formulation can be supplied to other customers.

These points should be documented rather than left to verbal understanding.

7. Ignoring communication and delivery commitments

Manufacturing involves several stages, and the brand owner needs regular updates.

If nobody communicates when samples are delayed, packaging is unavailable or production is rescheduled, the brand's sales planning can suffer.

Before placing an order, discuss the expected timeline, payment terms, dispatch responsibilities and process for handling quality complaints.

The best manufacturing relationship is not necessarily the one with the lowest quotation. It is the one where both parties understand their responsibilities.

How MGVS LifeSciences Supports Supplement Brands With Third Party Manufacturing

For someone entering the supplement business, finding a manufacturer who understands both product requirements and commercial expectations is important.

A new brand may not have an experienced procurement team, technical department or regulatory professional. It needs a manufacturing partner who can explain the process without making everything unnecessarily complicated.

MGVS LifeSciences operates in the Indian nutraceutical manufacturing space, with a focus on supporting businesses interested in developing and manufacturing dietary supplement products.

The manufacturing discussion should begin with the product rather than a generic package.

For example, an entrepreneur planning a sports nutrition brand may need support with protein powder manufacturing, mass gainer development or creatine products. Another business may be more interested in capsules, tablets, herbal supplements or multivitamin formulations.

These requirements involve different production considerations.

Support across different supplement categories

MGVS LifeSciences can be approached for manufacturing discussions involving product categories such as:

  • Protein and sports nutrition supplements

  • Vitamins and mineral formulations

  • Capsules and tablets

  • Herbal and nutritional supplements

  • Custom nutraceutical formulations

  • Private label supplement products

The suitable manufacturing arrangement depends on the specific product, formulation, production requirements and regulatory permissions.

Private label manufacturing for new businesses

Not every entrepreneur wants to develop a completely new formulation.

Some businesses prefer to select an existing product and introduce it under their own brand identity.

Private label supplement manufacturing can be a practical starting point for gym owners, distributors, wellness businesses and online supplement sellers.

The discussion generally covers product selection, packaging, label requirements, order quantity and commercial terms.

A gym owner, for example, may want to launch a protein supplement for existing customers. A distributor may be interested in creating a wider range of nutritional products for a regional market.

Both businesses have different sales objectives, even if they approach the same manufacturer.

Custom formulation and product development

Brands looking for a distinctive product can discuss custom nutraceutical formulation requirements.

This may involve ingredient combinations, nutritional specifications, product format, flavour preferences and packaging.

For a customised whey protein blend, the brand may want to discuss the protein source, flavour profile and nutritional composition.

For a herbal supplement, the focus may be on ingredient selection, extract specifications and applicable regulatory requirements.

The feasibility of a formulation depends on ingredient permissions, technical suitability, testing and production capabilities.

A practical approach to manufacturing enquiries

Before contacting MGVS LifeSciences, it helps to prepare a few basic details:

  1. Product name or category.

  2. Preferred formulation or ingredient requirements.

  3. Desired packaging format and pack size.

  4. Expected order quantity.

  5. Target customer and intended market.

  6. Whether you need private label or custom manufacturing.

These details make it easier to discuss the manufacturing requirements and understand the next steps.

You can explore the company's services and manufacturing information through the MGVS LifeSciences website.

The important thing is to discuss the actual product requirement, not simply ask for a general manufacturing price.